For the first time since the referendum one of the two historic main parties in the UK has made a broad commitment to Europe, and has included in that a serious option of rejoining the EU. Before the last few weeks Labour’s ambiguity and palpable anxiety about Europe has ensured that many remain voters preferred the Greens or the Lib Dems, both of whom have been positive about Europe since the referendum. Now Burnham’s explicit commitment is certain to bring some of those remain voters back to Labour. It’s a good time to do that, with the Lib Dems apparently doing nothing, and the Greens clearly doing some very unwise things.
However, to achieve the full possibilities of this realignment Labour would need to pull maximum votes from both the Greens and the Lib Dems; and that needs a broader appeal to those remain voters, as many of them are not exclusively motivated by Europe, but have other causes too. The problem is that the other causes that are likely to excite Lib Dem voters are not the same as the causes that would similarly appeal to Green voters. At present Labour is moving to the left, and that is more likely to attract Greens than Lib Dems. So there is an asymmetry. Nevertheless Labour is looking both more secure, and more pro-Europe, than they have done since the referendum. That must be good in the medium term.
In the long term, however, a stable return to Europe requires that the Conservatives become less virulently anti-EU, and more willing to compromise on the Europe issue. At present half of our political spectrum is tied to committed Brexit parties, and the likely outcome of Labour’s shift is that the UK will yoyo back and forth to and from Europe in accordance with the shifting balance of power between left and right in our home politics. In that event the EU would not want the grief of our involvement.
Is there any hope of a Conservative softening on Europe? There seems to be a pro- Europe residue who still identify as Conservative, represented particularly by the Conservative European Forum, who have their own organization and programme. They were permitted to hold meetings at the last Conservative party conference earlier in October, so they are presumably not complete outcasts. But they are careful not to advocate a return to full EU membership. They appear to concentrate on combining a vague message in favour of increasing links with Europe, with a narrow focus on the less controversial details of trade with the EU. They are explicit about the fact that some conservative voters are disillusioned with Brexit (the rest of the party presumably knows that but isn’t saying). Nonetheless Badenoch continues her purge of anyone who has doubts about leaving the ECHR, so its unlikely that she will give any ground on rejoining the EU. She can’t stop pro-Europeans from being members but she can stop them from being adopted as candidates, and she is doing precisely that. She seems mainly intent on competing with Reform for Brexit voters, keeping her candidates Brexit-pure and requiring Brexit-doubting conservative voters to swallow it. Maybe they will. But it also means that a tranche of Lib Dem voters who are despairing of Lib Dem inactivity and might have drifted back to a softer-Brexit conservatives party, won’t. I guess they will just stay at home.